Top 5 Takeaways on Developing Critical Thinking Skills for Theatre

Do your students know how to form their own artistic opinions without being swayed by others? Can they confidently stand by their perspective, even if they disagree with a show that has received glowing reviews?

Critical thinking is essential for students, especially in theatre, where responses are inherently subjective and there’s rarely a “right” or “wrong” answer. Here are our top five takeaways to help students develop these skills. What would you add to the list?

1. Form your own artistic opinion.

When you see a show, it’s easy to be swayed by critics, big names, or awards. But forming your own opinion is essential. Don’t assume a play is “good” just because it’s by a talented playwright or has famous actors. If something doesn’t connect with you, that’s valid! Just be ready to explain why.

2. Separate performance from play.

Even in productions where the script doesn’t resonate, you can still appreciate exceptional performances. Observing how actors inhabit their character through emotional connection, focus, and physicality can deepen your understanding of craft and character work.

3. Define your “theatrical experience.”

Theatre is hard to define because it means something different for every person who watches it. Where one person loves realism, another will live for musicals and another will only watch gritty abstract absurdism. This is what makes the live experience unique. When evaluating a play, ask: “What was my theatrical experience?” Did it engage you emotionally, intellectually, or visually? And why?

4. Question consensus and reviews.

When a show receives glowing reviews but leaves you cold, don’t dismiss your reaction. Critics view productions through their own lenses; what seems “fresh” to them may feel flat to you. Critical thinking means considering perspective, bias, and timing.

5. Understand the reality of the industry.

Behind every production are years of work, countless collaborators, and high stakes. Success and failure often hinge on timing, money, and creative compromise. Hearing professionals reflect honestly on their careers reminds us that perseverance, passion, and adaptability matter as much as talent.